This Product NOT Recommended: Mary Kay Eye Makeup Remover

So after editing my September favorites video, in which I talked about makeup remover wipes, I realized that I cut out the part where I asked for suggestions for a good makeup remover.

 I've gone through two bottles of Mary Kay's Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover, and I've learned that I absolutely cannot stand it any longer! I need something much much better. Let me point out a few things about why I don't like this product at all:

• Yes, this makeup remover removes your eye makeup, but not before smearing it all over your face.  I look more like a racoon after I use it than before. Isn't that defeating the purpose?
• On the bottle it says it's oil-free, but after using it, I normally have to wipe my face with a wet towel to get that oily feeling off my face.
• It says that it doesn't dry the skin, which is true. But it does dry out my eyes. Worst of all, it pushes all of my eyeliner into my eye, so when I open it and look at them, I can see black specks on the whites of my eyes. I'm not entirely sure how safe that is?

You get the point, don't you?  I'm almost out of my bottle, and I need to find a new one desparately!  Most of you know that I don't go a day without putting eye makeup on, so I need something fast.  Any suggestions? Post them below and I'll let you know which one I end up trying! :)